What to do when a candidate asks for more money

You have made the offer, the candidate has thanked you, and then comes the line every hiring manager half expects and rarely prepares for: "I was hoping we could talk about the salary." What happens in the next 48 hours can decide whether you secure the person you chose, at a number you can defend, or lose them to an employer that responded faster.

A request for more money is a normal part of the offer stage. It does not necessarily mean the candidate is unhappy with the offer or difficult to deal with. In many cases, they are simply checking whether there is any room to move before they make a final decision.

In this blog, we explain whether you should negotiate at all, why candidates ask, how to respond step by step, what to say in the three most common situations, when to hold firm and the mistakes that can turn a solvable request into a lost hire.

Should you negotiate when a candidate asks for more money?

In most cases, you should be open to the conversation. That does not mean you have to increase the offer, but it does mean hearing the candidate out and understanding what sits behind their request.

Check the ask against your salary band, the market rate, the candidate's experience and any internal pay considerations. Then come back with a clear answer, whether that is the original offer, a revised figure or another part of the package.

Negotiating does not mean agreeing. It means treating the request as a normal part of the offer process and making your decision based on what is fair, competitive and sustainable for the business.

Why do candidates ask for more money?

Understanding the reason behind the request changes how you respond to it. There are usually four.

Your offer is below the market rate

The most common reason is the simplest. The candidate has checked salary guides, spoken to a recruiter or seen what similar roles are advertising for, and your number sits below it. In that case, the request is information about your offer, not about the candidate.

Read more: Salary Benchmarking: A practical guide for employers

They have a competing offer

Candidates strong enough to reach your offer stage are often at the same point with someone else. A competing offer at a higher figure is a legitimate reason to ask, and it is worth knowing about, because it tells you exactly what you are competing against.

Their current employer has moved

Some candidates resign and are immediately offered more to stay. They come back to you not because they want to play games but because the gap between your offer and their new reality has changed. A quick, honest conversation usually resolves this one way or the other.

The benefits do not stack up

Sometimes the base salary is fine but the package behind it is weaker than their current one: less holiday, no bonus, a smaller pension contribution or a less flexible working pattern. A request for more money is often a request to close that gap, and there may be cheaper ways to close it than base salary.

How to respond when a candidate asks for more money

A good response takes a day or two and follows a clear sequence. Rushing it or dragging it out both cost you.

Do not react on the call

If the request comes by phone, thank them for being open, tell them you will consider it properly and give them a time by which you will come back. Do not say yes or no in the moment. A hasty yes sets a precedent you may regret, and a hasty no ends conversations that a day's thought would have saved.

Ask what sits behind the number

Before you decide anything, understand the request. Ask:

• Is there a specific figure they have in mind?

• Is the request based on market data, another offer or a counteroffer from their current employer?

• Is the issue the base salary or the overall package?

• Is there anything else influencing their decision?

The answers will help you understand what is driving the request and how much room there may be to respond.

Check the request against your band and your team

Look at where the requested figure sits within the salary band for the role and against what existing team members at the same level earn.

A request that lands inside the band and does not leapfrog current staff is usually straightforward to say yes to. A request that breaks the band or creates an internal pay gap needs more thought, because the cost of saying yes is not just this salary.

Read more: How to set salary bands for your business

Decide between four options

You have four realistic responses. Meet the request in full. Meet it partway with a revised figure. Hold the salary firm but improve something else, such as holiday, a review date, a signing bonus or flexibility. Or hold firm on everything and explain why. Each is legitimate. What matters is choosing deliberately and being able to explain the reasoning.

Respond within 24 to 48 hours

Speed matters as much as the answer. A candidate waiting a week to hear back about salary is a candidate who assumes the answer is no and keeps their other options warm. Come back inside two working days, by phone first, then confirm whatever you agree to in a revised written offer.

Read more: Why a lengthy hiring process is costing you top talent

What to say when a candidate asks for more money

Wording matters here, because the candidate is listening for how you treat people as much as for the number. Here is how to handle the three most common outcomes.

If you can meet the request

Say yes clearly and quickly, and frame it as a decision rather than a concession. For example:

"Thanks for being upfront about this. We've looked at it against the market and the role, and we're happy to move the salary to £52,000. I'll send the updated offer across this afternoon."

A clean yes builds loyalty before day one.

If you can meet them partway

Explain the reasoning and give a specific alternative. For example:

"We've looked at the £55,000 you mentioned. Our band for this role tops out at £52,000, and that's where we've placed the offer to keep pay fair across the team. What we can do is bring your first salary review forward to six months, with a clear set of objectives agreed at the start, so there's a defined route to the number you're looking for."

Candidates respond well to a firm figure with a visible path beyond it.

If you cannot move at all

Be honest, be specific and leave the decision with them. For example:

"I understand why you've asked, and I want to be straight with you. The offer is at the top of our range for this role, and moving it would put you ahead of people doing the same job with more experience, which isn't something we're prepared to do. The offer stands as it is, and we'd very much like you to accept it. Take a couple of days if you need to."

A respectful no loses fewer candidates than employers expect.

Read more: How to create an offer that gets accepted by top candidates

When should you hold firm?

Saying yes to every request is as damaging as refusing all of them. These are the situations where holding the line is the right call.

When the request breaks your salary band

Bands exist so that pay decisions are made once, on market data, rather than negotiation by negotiation. If a request would take the salary outside the band, the answer is either to re-benchmark the role because the band is wrong, or to hold firm because it is right. Approving an exception is how bands stop meaning anything.

When it would create unfairness in the team

Paying a new hire more than experienced people already doing the same job creates a problem that surfaces the moment pay is discussed internally, which it always is eventually. The cost of that is retention risk across the team, and it is rarely worth one hire.

Read more: Why employee retention matters (and how to improve it)

When the request keeps changing

A candidate who asks for more, receives it and then asks again is showing you something. One negotiation is normal. A moving target is not, and it is fair to say so and let the offer stand or fall on its current terms.

Mistakes to avoid when a candidate asks for more

Most offers lost at this stage are lost through avoidable errors rather than real gaps in budget.

Withdrawing the offer because they asked

Pulling an offer because a candidate negotiated is the single most damaging thing an employer can do at this stage. It signals a business that punishes people for advocating for themselves, and candidates tell each other. Say no if you need to. Do not say never mind.

Starting low to leave room

Some employers deliberately offer below what they are prepared to pay, expecting a negotiation. Candidates who accept without negotiating start underpaid and often find out later, and candidates who do negotiate now doubt the honesty of everything else you told them. Offer the number you believe is right for the role and defend it.

Going quiet while you decide

Silence is the most common reason a solvable request becomes a lost hire. Even if the decision takes a few days, tell the candidate when they will hear from you and keep to it.

Treating the request as a red flag

Asking for more money is not a sign of greed, disloyalty or a difficult employee to come. It is the behaviour of someone who knows their value, which is usually exactly the person you were trying to hire.

Read more: Setting realistic hiring expectations: What employers need to know

How a recruitment partner helps

A specialist recruiter takes most of the heat out of salary negotiation. They know what the candidate is really looking for, they know the market rate this month rather than last year, and they can carry a firm message from you without it becoming a personal standoff between the candidate and their future manager.

At Digital Waffle, we benchmark every role before it goes to market, so our clients rarely receive a request for more money that surprises them. When one does come, we handle the conversation, test what sits behind it and bring back a clear recommendation, backed by what we see candidates accepting every week.

A candidate asking for more money is not a problem to be managed. It is a normal part of hiring, and one of the few moments in the process where the candidate tells you exactly what they are thinking. Understand the reason, check it against your band and your team, decide quickly and explain your answer whatever it is. That is all a good response requires.

The employers who close offers most reliably are rarely the ones who pay the most. They are the ones who knew their number before the conversation started, could explain it in one sentence and treated the person asking with the respect they would want on day one.

Need support finding and securing top talent? Submit your vacancy and one of our consultants will be in touch to talk through what you need.